Gender differences in workaholism and work-related variables
Iwona Dudek 1  
,   Malwina Szpitalak 1  
 
More details
Hide details
1
Uniwersytet Jagielloński, Wydział Filozoficzny, Instytut Psychologii
Publication date: 2019-12-30
 
Studia Humanistyczne AGH 2019;18(4):59–76
 
ABSTRACT
The term ‘workaholism’ was first coined by Wayne Oates (1971), and since then it has been conceptualized in a variety of ways. Most researchers agree, however, that a defining feature of workaholism is that it involves an inner compulsion to work, in which people constantly think about work (Beiler-May, Williamson, Clark, Carter 2017). Conclusions on workaholism are often contradictory, which may reflect a shortage of research results (Burke 1999). This also applies to research on gender differences regarding workaholism and work-related variables. The results of several studies (e.g. Burgess, Burke, Oberklaid 2006; Burke 1999; Doerfler, Kammer 1986; Spence, Robbins 1992) have been equivocal (some of them indicate that there is no relationship between gender and workaholism, while others suggest that workaholism is related to gender). The purpose of this paper is to examine gender differences in five workaholism factors and the work-related variables of perfectionism and self-handicapping. Three hundred and fourteen participants (Mean age = 29.29; SD = 12.02) took part in the study. Questionnaires were administered in a paper version. Workaholism was measured using the 25-item Work Addiction Risk Test (Robinson 1998) in Polish adaptation (Wojdyło 2005), which measures different facets of workaholism (Obsession/Compulsion, Emotional Arousal/Perfectionism; Overdoing, Outcome Orientation and Self-Worth). To test perfectionism The Polish Adaptive and Maladaptive Perfectionism Questionnaire (Szczucka 2010) was used. Self-handicapping strategies were measured using the Anticipative Strategy of Self-Esteem Protection Scale (Doliński, Szmajke 1994). Females and males were found to differ on workaholism. Women were significantly higher on average in workaholism than men (a significant difference appeared in two of the five components: Overdoing and Emotional Arousal/Perfectionism). Females also reported higher levels of maladaptive perfectionism, which is considered as a workaholic job behavior. Gender differences have also been observed in self-handicapping strategies. Women were characterized by a stronger tendency towards self-justification then men. Males, on the other hand, declared stronger emotional resilience than women. These patterns of results are consistent with the results obtained in a previous study regarding gender differences in using self-handicapping strategies (Doliński, Szmajke 1994). The obtained results can be interpreted through the prism of the roles and tasks currently given to women. On the one hand, in light of social norms, a woman should take care of the household and family, while a man is responsible for earning money to support the family (Blair-Loy 2003). On the other hand, participation of women in the workforce is increasing (Peeters, Montgomery, Bakker, Schaufeli 2005), so they may find it difficult to reconcile work and fulfilling the demands of the roles of spouses, mothers or caregivers. Our study show that women may feel more overloaded with work and they have a higher level of emotional factors than men regarding workaholism. However, one may wonder whether women's workaholism is still underestimated. Women may find it more difficult to admit that they feel an inner compulsion to work due to gender-differentiated societal norms and expectations (Beiler-May et al. 2017: 109).
 
REFERENCES (73)
1.
Aziz, Shahnaz and Jamie Cunningham. 2008. Workaholism, work stress, work-life imbalance: exploring gender's role, “Gender in Management: An International Journal”, 23, no 8: 553-566.
 
2.
Bakker, Arnold B., Evangelia Demerouti, and Ronald Burke. 2009. Workaholism and relationship quality: A spillover-crossover perspective, “Journal of Occupational Health Psychology”, 14: 23-33.
 
3.
Barnett, Rosalind C., Karen C. Gareis, and Robert T. Brennan. 1999. Fit as a mediator of the relationship between work hours and burnout, “Journal of Occupational Health Psychology”, 4, no. 4: 307-317.
 
4.
Behson, Scott J. 2002. Coping with family-to-work conflict: The role of informal work accommodations to family, “Journal of Occupational Health Psychology”, 7, no. 4: 324-341.
 
5.
Beiler-May, Angela, Rachel L. Williamson, Malissa A. Clark, and Nathan T. Carter. 2017. Gender bias in the measurement of workaholism, “Journal of Personality Assessment”, 99, no. 1: 104-110.
 
6.
Berglas, Steven, and Edward E. Jones.1978. Drug choice as a self-handicapping strategy in response to noncontingent success, “Journal of Personality and Social Psychology”, 36, no. 4: 405-417.
 
7.
Burgess, Zena, Ronald J. Burke, and Fay Oberklaid. 2006. Workaholism among Australian psychologists: gender differences, “Equal Opportunities International”, 25, no. 1: 48-59.
 
8.
Burke, Ronald J. 1999. Workaholism in organizations: Gender differences, “Sex Roles”, 41, no. 5-6: 333-345.
 
9.
Burke, Ronald J., Richard A. Davis, and Gordon L. Flett. 2008. Workaholism Types-Perfectionism and Work Outcomes, “ISGUC The Journal of Industrial Relations and Human Resources”, 10, no. 4: 30-40.
 
10.
Burke, Ronald J., Zena Burgess, and Barry Fallon. 2006. Workaholism among Australian female managers and professionals: Job behaviors, satisfactions and psychological health, “Equal Opportunities International”, 25, no. 3: 200-213.
 
11.
Craik, Kenneth H. 2007. Taxonomies, trends, and integrations. In: Robins, Richard W. , Chris Fraley, and Robert F. Krueger (eds), Handbook of research methods in personality psychology, New York: Guilford Publications, pp. 209-223.
 
12.
Doerfler, Marie Christine, and Phyllis Post Kammer. 1986. Workaholism, sex, and sex role stereotyping among female professionals, “Sex Roles”, 14, no. 9-10: 551-560.
 
13.
Doliński, Dariusz and Andrzej Szmajke. 1994. “Samoutrudnianie”, Olsztyn: PTP.
 
14.
Dunkley, David M., David C. Zuroff, and Kirk R. Blankstein. 2003. Self-critical perfectionism and daily affect: Dispositional and situational influences on stress and coping, “Journal of Personality and Social Psychology”, 84, no. 1: 234-252.
 
15.
Fassel, Diane. 1990. Working ourselves to death: The high cost of workaholism, the rewards of recovery, San Francisco: Harper Collins.
 
16.
Freeman, Joan. 2004. Cultural influences on gifted gender achievement, “High Ability Studies”, 15, no. 1: 7-23.
 
17.
Galperin, Bella L., and Ronald J. Burke. 2006. Uncovering the relationship between workaholism and workplace destructive and constructive deviance: An exploratory study, “The International Journal of Human Resource Management “, 17, no. 2: 331-347.
 
18.
Garson, Bonnie. 2005. Work addiction in the age of information technology: An analysis. “IIMB Management Review”, 15: 21.
 
19.
Golińska, Lucyna. 2008. Pracoholizm: uzależnienie czy pasja, Warszawa: Difin.
 
20.
Graves, Laura, Marian N. Ruderman, and Patricia J. Ohlott. 2006. Effect of workaholism on managerial performance: Help or hindrance?, “Academy of Management Proceedings”, 1, A1-A6.
 
21.
Hamachek, Don E. 1978. Psychodynamics of normal and neurotic perfectionism, “Psychology: A Journal of Human Behavior”, 15, no. 1:27-33.
 
22.
Hanson, P. 1985. Stress for success: How to make stress on the job work for you. New York: Doubleday.
 
23.
Harpaz, Itzhak, and Raphael Snir. 2003. Workaholism: Its definition and nature, “Human Relations”, 56, no. 3: 291-319.
 
24.
Harris, Robert N., and C. R. Snyder. 1986. The role of uncertain self-esteem in self-handicapping, “Journal of Personality and Social Psychology”, 51, no. 2: 451-458.
 
25.
Hayes, A. F. (2018). Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis. A regression-based approach (second edition), New York: The Guilford Press.
 
26.
Hirt, Edward R., Roberta K. Deppe, and Lesley J. Gordon. 1991. Self-reported versus behavioral self-handicapping: Empirical evidence for a theoretical distinction, “Journal of Personality and Social Psychology”, 61, no. 6: 981-991.
 
27.
Killinger, Barbara. 1991. Workaholics: The respectable addicts, Buffalo, NY: Firefly.
 
28.
Kimble, Charles E., Emily A. Kimble, and Nan A. Croy. 1998. Development of self-handicapping tendencies, “The Journal of Social Psychology”, 138, no. 4: 524-534.
 
29.
Korn, Errol R., George J. Pratt, and Peter T. Lambrou. 1987. Hyper-performance: The AIM strategy for releasing your business potential, New York: John Wiley & Sons.
 
30.
Kosakowska, Natasza, and Paulina Petrus. 2006. Kobieta na „dwóch etatach”, czyli jakość funkcjonowania kobiet w małżeństwie dwu karier, “Psychologia Rozwojowa”, 11, no. 3: 163-174.
 
31.
Lewandowska-Walter, Aleksandra, and Kamila Wojdyło. 2011. Ex Post Perception of Parental Attitudes of People with a Tendency to Workaholism, “Studia Psychologiczne”, 49, no. 2: 35-52.
 
32.
Lichtenstein, Mia Beck, Erik Christiansen, Ask Elklit, Niels Bilenberg, and René Klinky Støving. 2014. Exercise addiction: a study of eating disorder symptoms, quality of life, personality traits and attachment styles, “Psychiatry Research”, 215, no. 2: 410-416.
 
33.
Machlowitz, Marilyn. 1980. Workaholics, living with them, working with them, Boston: Addison Wesley Publishing Company.
 
34.
Malinowska, Diana, Sabina Staszczyk, and Aleksandra Tokarz. 2015. Pracoholizm: wskazania dotyczące diagnozy oraz przegląd działań interwencyjnych, “Medycyna Pracy”, 66, no. 1: 71-83.
 
35.
Naughton, Thomas J. 1987. A conceptual view of workaholism and implications for career counseling and research, “The Career Development Quarterly”, 35, no. 3:180-187.
 
36.
Ng, Thomas WH, Kelly L. Sorensen, and Daniel C. Feldman. 2007. Dimensions, antecedents, and consequences of workaholism: A conceptual integration and extension, “Journal of Organizational Behavior: The International Journal of Industrial, Occupational and Organizational Psychology and Behavior”, 28, no. 1: 111-136.
 
37.
Oates, Wayne Edward. 1971. Confessions of a workaholic: The facts about work addiction, New York: World Publishing Company.
 
38.
Ozbilir, Timur, Arla Day, and Victor M. Catano. 2015. Perfectionism at Work: An Investigation of Adaptive and Maladaptive Perfectionism in the Workplace among Canadian and Turkish Employees, “Applied Psychology”, 64, no. 1: 252-280.
 
39.
Paulhus, Delroy and Simine Vazire. 2007. The self-report method, In: Robins, Richard W., R. Chris Fraley, and Robert F. Krueger (eds), Handbook of research methods in personality psychology, New York, NY: Guilford Press, pp. 224–239.
 
40.
Peplińska, Aleksandra, Kamila Wojdyło, Natasza Kosakowska-Berezecka, and Piotr Połomski. 2015. The role of purpose in life and social support in reducing the risk of workaholism among women in Poland, “Health Psychology Report”, 3, no. 4: 326-335.
 
41.
Piotrowski, Chris, and Stephen J. Vodanovich. 2006. The interface between workaholism and work-family conflict: A review and conceptual framework, “Organization Development Journal”, 24, no. 4: 84-92.
 
42.
Porter, Gayle. 1996. Organizational impact of workaholism: Suggestions for researching the negative outcomes of excessive work, “Journal of occupational health psychology”, 1, no. 1 70-84.
 
43.
Porter, Gayle. 2001. Workaholic tendencies and the high potential for stress among co-workers, “International Journal of Stress Management”, 8, no. 2: 147-164.
 
44.
Reeves, S. 2005. Addicted to work. “Forbes”, November,17.
 
45.
Retna, Kala S., Amanda Smith, and John Davies. 2017. Gender and Workaholism in New Zealand, “New Zealand Journal of Human Resources Management”, 17, no. 1: 36-53.
 
46.
Rhodewalt, Frederic. 1990. Self-handicappers: Individual differences in the preference for anticipatory, self-protective acts, In: Higgins, Raymond, Charles Snyder, and Steven Berglas (Eds.), “Self-handicapping: The paradox that isn’t”, New York: Plenum, pp. 69–106.
 
47.
Rhodewalt, Frederick, and James Davison Jr. 1986. Self-handicapping and subsequent performance: Role of outcome valence and attributional certainty, “Basic and Applied Social Psychology”, 7, no. 4: 307-322.
 
48.
Rice, Kenneth G., and Amy C. Van Arsdale. 2010. Perfectionism, perceived stress, drinking to cope, and alcohol-related problems among college students, “Journal of Counseling Psychology”, 57, no. 4: 439-450.
 
49.
Robinson, Bryan E., and Bruce Phillips. 1995. Measuring workaholism: content validity of the Work Addiction Risk Test, “Psychological Reports”, 77, no. 2:657-658.
 
50.
Robinson, Bryan E., and Lisa Kelley. 1998. Adult children of workaholics: Self-concept, anxiety, depression, and locus of control, “American Journal of Family Therapy”, 26.3: 223-238.
 
51.
Robinson, Bryan E. 2014. Chained to the desk: A guidebook for workaholics, their partners and children, and the clinicians who treat them, New York: NYU Press.
 
52.
Rosa, Roger. 1995. Extended workshifts and excessive fatigue, “Journal of Sleep Research”, 4, 51-56.
 
53.
Russo, James A., and Lea E. Waters. 2006. Workaholic worker type differences in work-family conflict: The moderating role of supervisor support and flexible work scheduling, “Career Development International”, 11, no. 5: 418-439.
 
54.
Salmela-Aro, Katariina, Asko Tolvanen, and Jari-Erik Nurmi. 2011. Social strategies during university studies predict early career work burnout and engagement: 18-year longitudinal study, “Journal of Vocational Behavior”, 79, no. 1: 145-157.
 
55.
Schaufeli, Wilmar B., Marisa Salanova, Vicente González-Romá, and Arnold B. Bakker. 2002. The measurement of engagement and burnout: A two sample confirmatory factor analytic approach, “Journal of Happiness Studies”, 3, no. 1: 71-92.
 
56.
Scott, Kimberly S., Keirsten S. Moore, and Marcia P. Miceli. 1997. An exploration of the meaning and consequences of workaholism, “Human Relations”, 50, no. 3: 287-314.
 
57.
Şenormancı, Ömer, Özge Saraçlı, Nuray Atasoy, Güliz Şenormancı, Fürüzan Koktürk, and Levent Atik. 2014. Relationship of Internet addiction with cognitive style, personality, and depression in university students, “Comprehensive Psychiatry”, 55, no. 6: 1385-1390.
 
58.
Sierota, Agata. 2003. Płeć a strategia samoutrudniania, “Przegląd Psychologiczny”, 46: 409-424.
 
59.
Slaney, Robert B., Kenneth G. Rice, Michael Mobley, Joseph Trippi, and Jeffrey S. Ashby. 2001. The revised almost perfect scale, “Measurement and evaluation in counseling and development”, 34, no. 3: 130-146.
 
60.
Snir, Raphael, and Itzhak Harpaz. 2004. Attitudinal and demographic antecedents of workaholism, “Journal of Organizational Change Management”, 17, no. 5: 520-536.
 
61.
Spence, Janet T., and Ann S. Robbins. 1992. Workaholism: Definition, measurement, and preliminary results, “Journal of Personality Assessment”, 58, no. 1: 160-178.
 
62.
Sprankle, Judith K., and Henry Ebel. 1987. The workaholic syndrome, New York: Walker.
 
63.
Stoeber, Joachim, Charlotte R. Davis, and Jessica Townley. 2013. Perfectionism and workaholism in employees: The role of work motivation, “Personality and Individual Differences”, 55, no. 7: 733-738.
 
64.
Szczucka, Katarzyna. 2010. Polski Kwestionariusz Perfekcjonizmu Adaptacyjnego i Dezadaptacyjnego, “Psychologia Społeczna”, 5: 71-95.
 
65.
Szpitalak, Malwina. 2012. Wielowymiarowy kwestionariusz oceny pracoholizmu, Kraków: Wydawnictwo UJ.
 
66.
Taris, Toon W., Wilmar B. Schaufeli, and Lotus C. Verhoeven. 2005. Workaholism in the Netherlands: Measurement and implications for job strain and work–nonwork conflict, “Applied Psychology”, 54, no. 1: 37-60.
 
67.
Wojdyło, Kamila and Aleksandra Lewandowska-Walter. 2010. Pracoholizm a płeć i style przywiązaniowe, In: Chybicka, Anna and Natasza Kosakowska-Berezecka (Eds.), Między płcią a rodzajem: teorie, badania, aplikacje, Kraków: Oficyna Wydawnicza "Impuls", pp. 133-149.
 
68.
Wojdyło, Kamila, and Aleksandra Lewandowska-Walter. 2009. Kontrola działania u osób uzależnionych od pracy, “Przegląd Psychologiczny”, 52, no. 4: 453-471.
 
69.
Wojdyło, Kamila. 2003. Charakterystyka problemu uzależnienia od pracy w świetle dotychczasowych badań, “Nowiny Psychologiczne”, 3: 33–50.
 
70.
Wojdyło, Kamila. 2005. Kwestionariusz Pracoholizmu (WART)–adaptacja narzędzia i wstępna analiza własności psychometrycznych, “Nowiny Psychologiczne”, 4: 71-84.
 
71.
Wojdyło, Kamila. 2007. A conception of personal determinants of workaholism: evidence from the correlation model, “Studia Psychologiczne”, 3, no. 45: 53-65.
 
72.
Wojdyło, Kamila. 2013. Work Craving – teoria uzależnienia od pracy, “Nauka”, 3: 87-97.
 
73.
Worrall, Les, Cary Cooper, and Fiona Campbell. 2000. The impact of organizational change on UK managers’ perceptions of their working lives, In: Burke, Roland and Cary L. Cooper (Eds.) The organization in crisis: Downsizing, restructuring, and privatization, Oxford: Blackwell Publishers, pp. 20-43.